MMC NOTEBOOK - NOTE #A2: PRIMARY, SECONDARY &
SYNTHESIZING SOURCES
SOURCES of information for original
research, college course term papers, essays and other scholarly
works come in several types. They are primary sources, secondary
sources and synthesizing sources. The quality of scholarship is
judged and the credence given to conclusions is often dependent on
the writer’s use of primary and secondary sources.
PRIMARY SOURCES
Primary sources are the original items
which have been produced by an author, artist, diarist, musician,
scientist, etc. The documents or objects of primary data are
studied, assessed, evaluated and commented upon by researcher or
student. What is considered a primary source may vary from
discipline to discipline. It may vary within a discipline because
one person may use an item as a primary source and another may
regard it as secondary. Every step away from the original increases
the possibility of misinterpretation of the original
meaning.
Primary data is that which has no
precedent. In any historical research it is the experience of those
who were there. It is the personal observations of the scientist
reporting his/her work. Primary literature is found in books,
magazine and journal articles, manuscripts, archives, newspapers,
government publications and documents, diaries, maps, tapes and
other artifacts. Microform copies of such works are sometimes used
as primary sources.
SECONDARY
SOURCES
Secondary sources are the books, journal
articles, magazine and newspaper accounts, films, etc. which have
been written about the person, item or topic in question. Book
reviews, literary and scientific criticism, essays, biographical
sources and bibliographies are secondary sources. Sometimes
secondary sources are the only and best information available. They
may also be the focus of your current research activity.
It is important for students to learn
about the use of primary and secondary sources when studying an
issue or topic. The synthesizing sources and finding aids direct
searchers to both of the above source types.
SYNTHESIZING
SOURCES
Synthesizing sources are the
encyclopedias, specialized dictionaries, discipline handbooks,
reviews of literature and reference works which summarize the "state
of the art" about a subject or topic at a particular time. When
starting to learn about a subject, synthesizing sources written by
experts are the best place to begin. The cited references in
synthesizing and secondary sources can direct searchers to primary
sources. They are also an indication of the thoroughness of these
sources and an indication of their reliability. Synthesizing sources
are a good place to start.
FINDING AIDS
The following set and sequence of finding
aids will assist in locating information from all three types of
sources described above.
1. Library Catalog. Card catalog or computer database, the library
catalog directs to its holdings. The Busse Center Library's catalog
has several indexes so it may be searched by subject, author, and
keyword. A keyword search will search for the word within a
subject heading. Most college catalogs use Library of Congress
Subject Headings. Use the large red LCSH books to find the subject
heading(s) commonly used for the topic you are
researching.
The books in the catalog are identified
as reference books or reserve books if they are not circulating
books (may be checked out). The indexes and lists of references at
the end of chapters or end of books are helpful in locating source
materials. Audiovisual (videos, tapes, kits, slides, CD's) materials
are also cataloged.
2. Reference Books. The general and specialized dictionaries,
encyclopedias, handbooks, almanacs, literature reviews, legal
materials, census and statistical materials are found in the
Reference Section of the library.
These are excellent starting points and
are the synthesizing sources mentioned on page 1. Again, pay heed to
the lists of references.
The Busse Library also maintains a
Desktop Reference collection of websites similar to the materials
held in a print reference section. This permits you 24 hour
access to reference works.
3. Periodical Indexes. Paper, CD-ROM and online databases index and
sometimes abstract large collections of citations of literature
published throughout the world. It is important to select the
correct database(s) for the topic under investigation. Busse Library
subscribes to many electronic periodical indexes and full-text
article databases. These are accessed on campus from the
Periodical and Other Databases webpage.
Periodical indexes often have lists of
subject headings or a thesaurus which alert the user to the terms
used in that particular database for the subjects included. The
terms used may vary considerably from database to database. Use
them. Electronic periodical indexes can also be searched by
keywords.
Most databases will have some information
on most topics. However each database indexes a segment of the
available literature. Some databases cover specific topics more
thoroughly because of the periodicals included. Compare your
findings as you go along.
Note# A8 summarizes the print
PERIODICAL INDEXES in the Busse Center Library. Use it to
help select the most appropriate starting points or the next step on
your search.
4. Newspaper Indexes. Some periodical indexes include citations to
newspaper articles and full-text articles. There are also databases
which are only of newspapers. Many short and unsupported articles
are indexed from newspapers, so it pays to analyze the citation
carefully. This can reduce frustration. MMC Notebook Note #C2
offers suggestions for evaluating citations which are especially
useful reminders when collecting newspaper citations.
5. Government Publications.
The various governments and
governmental agencies around the world produce and store vast
amounts of primary and secondary source material on every imaginable
topic. They also produce synthesizing documents in the form of
censuses, statistical compilations, etc. The Busse Center Library
collects some government publications which are integrated into the
Reference and regular Circulating Collections. There are also many
governmental websites linked to the Desktop Reference
pages.
6. Use your contacts and your
senses. Ask your instructors for
suggestions of source materials. Ask the reference librarians.
Browse periodicals, newspapers and the books in the vicinity of
those you locate using the Library Catalog. Listen to the radio and
watch television to collect information as well as to be
entertained. Much relevant and useful information is found
serendipitously. You never know when a reference will be
handy.